First team-offense
E - T.J. Smith, Rye-1, sr.
E - Ifeany Momah, John Glenn-1, sr.
L - Torrell Northrup, Geneva-5, sr.
L - Josh Cary, Chenango Forks-4, sr.
L - Erik Antico, Rye-1, sr.
L - Brad Serini, Highland-9, sr.
QB - Bryan Lance, Chenango Forks-4, sr.
RB - Curtis Underwood, Lackawanna-6, sr.
RB - Lewis Dendy, Bishop Ford-NYC, jr.
RB - Brian Fowler, Geneva-5, sr.
RB - Dave Zapata, Hornell-5, jr.

First-team defense
L - Fran Archibald, Rye-1, sr.
L - Joe Webb, Lackawanna-6, jr.
L - Joe Nicholson, Chenango Forks-4, sr.
L - Matt Brennan, Maryvale-6, sr.
L - J.B. Welling, Rye-1, sr.
LB - Dan Contrastano, Hastings-1, sr.
LB - Brandon Moyer, Canenovia-3, sr.
HB - Max Einhorn - Edgemont-1, sr.
HB - James Wittpen, Mount Sinai-11, sr.
K - A.J. DeLago, Albany Academy-2, sr.

Second-team offense
E - Art Bigsby, Cazenovia-3, jr.
E - Greg Schiefen, Elmira Notre Dame-4, sr.
L - Kelvin Cruz, Geneva-5, sr.
L - Dan McBride, Ravena-2, sr.
L - Abdullah Hadi, Lackawanna-6, sr.
L - Chris Meattey, Windsor-4, sr.
L - Zack Morgan, Homer-3, sr.
QB - Dan Fetter, Syracuse Westhill-3, sr.
RB - Dion Lewis, Albany Academy-2, jr.
RB - Connor O'Grady, Rye-1, sr.
RB - Dale Ross, Syracuse Westhill-3, jr.
RB - Kevin Dukes, Medina-6, sr.

Second-team defense
L - Kareem Smith, Nanuet-1, sr.
L - G.O. Ozkhan, Bishop Ford-NYC, jr.
L - Mike Cioffi, Albany Academy-2, sr.
L - David Etter, Cazenovia-3, sr.
L - Sam Austin, Hornell-5, jr.
LB - Bill Smith, Nanuet-1, jr.
LB - Ross Mosher, Red Hook-9, sr.
LB - John Warner, Geneva-5, sr.
DB - Chris Stoddard, Jamestown Southwestern-6, sr.
DB - Trevor Coston, John Glenn-11, sr.
HB - Andy Wade, East Aurora-6, sr.

Third-team offense
E - Jeff Watson, Marcellus-3, jr.
E - Matt Gray, Pelham-1, sr.
L - Jud Dubois, Chenango Forks-4, jr.
L - Jon Morrison, Homer-3, sr.
L - James Cantele, Hudson-2, sr.
L - Doug Koczan, Owego Free-4, sr.
QB - Dunea Lockwood, Cobleskill-2, sr.
RB - Mark Brenchley, Homer-3, sr.
RB - Josh Mateo, Waterloo-5, jr.
RB - Willie Simon, Hudson-2, sr.
RB - James Petracca, Manhasset-8, sr.

Third-team defense
L - Bryant Homerda, Elmira Notre Dame-4, sr.
L - Jeff Sann, Holland Patent-3, sr.
E - Cody Whitman, Windsor-4, sr.
LB - Mike Maney, Penn Yan-5, jr.
LB - Carlton Bynum, Depew-6, sr.
HB - Brett Williams, Hudson-2, sr.
HB - Marcus Rivers, Lackawanna-6, sr.
HB - Adam Ghitelman, Cold Spring Harbor-8, sr.
HB - Mike Sanders, Depew-6, sr.
DB - Ishmoile Muhammad, Babylon-11, sr.
DB - Eric Wild, Depew-6, sr.