First team-offense
E - Mike Humphrey, sr., LeRoy-5
E - Kevin Hanson, sr., Fonda-Fultonville-2
L - Steve Barrett, sr., Bishop Ludden-3
L - Jasen Carlson, jr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
L - Allen Ashlaw, sr., Saranac Lake-7
L - Curtis Hairston, sr., Cleveland Hill-6
QB - Zack Sopak, jr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
RB - Nick Finger, sr., Millbrook-9
RB - Jesse Debiase, sr., Westlake-1
RB - Rob Alexander, sr., Dobbs Ferry-1
RB - Dan Luntz, sr., Croton-Harmon-1

First-team defense
E - Devonte Brailsford, jr., Dobbs Ferry-1
L - Kyle Ray, sr., Unatego-4
L - Chris Williams, sr., Oakfield-Alabama-5
LB - Nate Stewart, sr., Bishop Ludden-3
LB - Nick Mainiero, sr., Croton-Harmon-1
LB - Matt Buice, sr., Elmira Notre Dame-4
LB - Bryan Schweitzer, sr., Babylon-11
HB - Whakeem Wiggins, sr., Cleveland-6
HB - Nate Whittaker, sr., Greene-4
HB - Mike Huffner, sr., Elmira Notre Dame-4
K - T.J. Losowski, sr., Westmoreland-3

Second-team offense
E - Matt Schuster, sr., Dansville-5
E - Steven Roland, sr., Fieldston-NYC
L - Zach Roberts, jr., Silver Creek-6
L - Neil Baron, sr., Westmoreland-3
L - J.C. Tretter, sr., Akron-6
L - Cody Headwell, jr., Fonda-Filtonville-2
QB - Travis Fenstermaker, sr., LeRoy-5
RB - Levi Bursch, jr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
RB - Dan Datino, sr., Rye Neck-1
RB - Omar Osbourne, jr., Bishop Ludden-3
RB - Scott Dunlap, sr., Adirondack-3

Second-team defense
E - Dan Carlin, sr., Greene-4
L - C.J. Haviland, sr., Rye Neck-1
L - Shane Larkin, sr., Schuylerville-2
L - Quinten Harrington, sr., Cambridge-2
L - Michael Corveddu, sr., Croton-Harmon-1
LB - Ryan Buzzetto, jr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
LB - Caleb Gleason, sr., Watervliet-2
HB - Steve Burpoe, sr., Saranac Lake-7
HB - Dan Imfeld, sr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
HB - John Rooney, jr., Bishop Ludden-3
K - Chris Rogers, jr., Cazenovia-3

Third-team offense
E - Tom Moore, sr., Croton-Harmon-1
E - Joe Tralli, Croton-Harmon-1
L - A.J. Boriello, Ellenville-9
L - Frank Halstead, sr., Chatham-2
L - Mark Tesseyman, jr., Sullivan West-9
L - Greg Peterson, sr., Schuylerville-2
QB - Josh Nethaway, sr., Fonda-Fultonville-2
RB - Tim Smith, sr., Oakfield-Alabama-5
RB - Dan Exner, sr., Ellenville-9
RB - Justin Becker, jr., Westmoreland-3
QB - Cole Marcoux, jr., Fieldston-NYC

Third-team defense
L - Brent Matazinsky, sr., Tamarac-2
L - Will Carter, sr., Westlake-1
LB - Sean Dougherty, sr., Cazenovia-3
LB - Evan Sylor, sr., Letchworth-5
LB - Shaquille Dudley, sr., Cardinal O'Hara-CHS-6
LB - Sir Aaron Taylor, sr., Lincoln Hall-1
LB - Jon Barge, sr., Saranac Lake-7
HB - Parker Niles, sr., Chatham-2
HB - Austin Bateman, jr., Schuylerville-2
HB - Kyle Eisnor, sr., Westmoreland-3
K - Mike Guerriere, sr., Sidney-4